Why Is a Reference Microbial Strain Used in Routine Testing?

In pharmaceutical microbiology laboratories, test results must be reliable, consistent, and scientifically justified. But how can a microbiologist confirm that a culture medium supports microbial growth or that a microbiological test is performing as expected?

One important way is by using a reference microbial strain.

A reference microbial strain is a well-characterized microorganism obtained from a recognized culture collection or an appropriately qualified commercial source. It is used as a standard organism in laboratory testing to evaluate the performance of culture media, verify test methods, and monitor the reliability of microbiological procedures.

Without suitable reference strains, laboratories may find it difficult to demonstrate that their testing methods are performing consistently.

What Is a Reference Microbial Strain?

A reference microbial strain is an authenticated microorganism with an established identity and documented origin. It serves as a standard against which laboratory testing performance can be evaluated.

These strains are commonly obtained from recognized culture collections, such as the American Type Culture Collection (ATCC), or from qualified suppliers providing traceable microbial preparations.

Each strain is identified by a specific name and accession number.

Examples commonly used in pharmaceutical microbiology include:

Microorganism Example ATCC number
Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 6538
Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC 9027
Escherichia coli ATCC 8739
Bacillus subtilis ATCC 6633
Candida albicans ATCC 10231
Aspergillus brasiliensis ATCC 16404

These are examples of strains used in specified pharmaceutical microbiological tests. The exact organisms required depend on the applicable pharmacopoeial chapter and test procedure.

Why Are Reference Microbial Strains Used in Routine Testing?

1. To Perform Growth Promotion Testing

https://pharmavk.com/why-is-growth-promotion-testing-gpt-performed/

One of the major applications of reference microbial strains is Growth Promotion Testing (GPT).

GPT checks whether a culture medium can support the growth of the microorganisms it is intended to recover.

For example, when a new batch of Soybean-Casein Digest Agar (SCDA) is prepared, suitable reference organisms may be inoculated according to the approved test procedure.

If the expected microbial growth is obtained within the specified acceptance criteria, the medium demonstrates suitable growth-supporting properties.

If growth is not satisfactory, the laboratory must investigate before approving the medium for use.

2. To Verify Microbiological Test Performance

Reference strains help demonstrate that a microbiological test is capable of detecting or recovering the microorganisms it is intended to detect.

They are used in procedures such as:

  • Microbial enumeration testing
  • Specified microorganism testing
  • Sterility testing method suitability
  • Antimicrobial effectiveness testing
  • Other microbiological method verification activities

The specific control organisms and acceptance criteria depend on the test being performed.

3. To Evaluate Culture Media Quality

https://pharmavk.com/culture-media-dehydration/

Culture media must have suitable nutritional and performance characteristics to support microbial recovery.

A medium may appear normal in colour, clarity, and consistency but still fail to support adequate microbial growth.

Using appropriate reference strains helps identify this problem before the medium is used for routine testing.

This is why visual inspection alone is not sufficient to establish media performance.

4. To Improve Consistency Between Testing Activities

Using authenticated reference strains helps laboratories maintain consistency between different testing sessions, analysts, and media batches.

Since the organism has a documented identity and source, it provides a more reliable basis for comparing test performance than an unidentified laboratory culture.

This supports reproducibility and strengthens confidence in microbiological results.

5. To Support Method Suitability Studies

Certain pharmaceutical products may contain antimicrobial ingredients or other substances that interfere with microbial recovery.

Method suitability testing evaluates whether the test procedure can recover microorganisms in the presence of the product.

Known reference strains are used as challenge organisms in accordance with the applicable method.

For example, if a product contains a preservative, the preservative may inhibit microbial growth during testing. A suitable method may require validated neutralization or another approach to demonstrate adequate microbial recovery.

6. To Support Laboratory Quality Control

Reference strains are an important part of a microbiology laboratory’s quality control programme.

They help establish confidence in:

  • Culture media performance
  • Microbiological test methods
  • Organism recovery
  • Routine laboratory procedures
  • Ongoing test performance

However, reference strains do not replace other quality controls, such as equipment qualification, analyst training, environmental controls, and proper documentation.

How Are Reference Microbial Strains Managed in a Laboratory?

Reference strains must be handled carefully to maintain their identity, purity, viability, and expected characteristics.

A typical strain management process includes:

Step 1: Procurement

Obtain the reference strain from a recognized culture collection or a qualified supplier. Verify the strain identity, certificate or documentation, and traceability.

Step 2: Receipt and Verification

Check the received material against the purchase and supplier documentation. Review the strain identification, lot details, storage conditions, and expiry information, where applicable.

Step 3: Preparation of Reference Stock

Prepare and preserve reference stocks according to an approved procedure and the supplier’s instructions.

Step 4: Preparation of Working Cultures

Prepare working cultures from the reference stock while controlling the number of passages.

Step 5: Routine Use

Use the working culture for the intended microbiological test, following the approved procedure for inoculum preparation, concentration, storage, and use.

Step 6: Documentation

Maintain records of strain identification, source, lot number, passage history, preparation date, storage conditions, and usage.

Why Is Passage Number Important?

A passage refers to the transfer of microorganisms from an established culture to fresh growth medium.

Repeated subculturing may lead to changes in microbial characteristics, including growth behaviour or other properties relevant to testing.

Therefore, laboratories should control and document the passage history of reference strains.

The FDA Pharmaceutical Microbiology Manual (2020) states that seed-lot cultures used for specified microbiological testing should not be more than five passages removed from the original master seed lot. The applicable pharmacopoeial chapter, strain supplier instructions, and approved laboratory procedure should always be checked for the relevant limit.

A controlled seed-lot system helps maintain consistency and reduces the risk of using cultures that have undergone excessive subculturing.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Handling Reference Strains

Common mistake Possible impact
Using an unidentified culture Uncertainty about organism identity
Exceeding the approved passage limit Potential changes in strain characteristics
Improper storage Loss of viability or altered performance
Inadequate labelling Strain mix-ups and traceability issues
Using expired or unsuitable preparations Unreliable test performance
Missing preparation records Difficulty investigating unexpected results
Using an incorrect inoculum Invalid or misleading test results

Reference strains should always be handled by trained personnel using approved procedures and appropriate biosafety practices.

Practical Example from a Pharmaceutical Microbiology Laboratory

Imagine a microbiologist receives a newly prepared batch of SCDA for routine microbial enumeration testing.

Before releasing the medium for use, the laboratory performs Growth Promotion Testing using the required reference microbial strains.

During testing, one of the organisms does not show the expected growth response.

The microbiologist should not immediately assume that the organism is unsuitable or repeat the test without investigation.

The laboratory should review relevant factors, such as:

  • Reference strain identity and passage history
  • Culture viability and inoculum preparation
  • Media preparation and sterilization records
  • Incubation conditions
  • Test procedure and acceptance criteria

The investigation helps determine whether the issue is related to the culture, medium, testing conditions, or another factor.

This example shows why reference strains are essential: they help laboratories identify potential problems before a medium or method is relied upon for routine testing.

Conclusion

Reference microbial strains play an important role in pharmaceutical microbiology by providing authenticated organisms for evaluating culture media, verifying microbiological test performance, and supporting method suitability studies.

Their correct identification, storage, passage control, and documentation are essential for maintaining reliable laboratory results.

In routine testing, a reference strain is more than just a microorganism used for inoculation. It is a quality control tool that helps demonstrate whether the laboratory’s microbiological testing process is performing as expected.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What is the main purpose of a reference microbial strain?

Its main purpose is to provide an authenticated microorganism for evaluating culture media, verifying microbiological test performance, and supporting method suitability studies.

2. What is the difference between a reference strain and a laboratory isolate?

A reference strain has an established identity and traceable source from a recognized culture collection or qualified supplier. A laboratory isolate is a microorganism recovered from a sample, product, environment, or manufacturing area.

3. What does ATCC mean?

ATCC stands for American Type Culture Collection. It is a biological resource centre that provides authenticated microbial strains and other biological materials.

4. Why is passage control important?

Passage control helps reduce the risk of changes in microbial characteristics caused by repeated subculturing and supports consistency in routine testing.

5. Are reference strains used only for Growth Promotion Testing?

No. They are also used in microbiological method suitability, specified microorganism testing, antimicrobial effectiveness testing, and other quality control activities, depending on the applicable procedure.

6. Can a laboratory isolate replace a reference strain?

Not automatically. The suitability of an alternative strain depends on the applicable pharmacopoeial requirements, method, and documented qualification or equivalence assessment.

References

1. U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Pharmaceutical Microbiology Manual, ORA.007, Revision 02, 2020.
Read the FDA Pharmaceutical Microbiology Manual

2. U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Microbiological Pharmaceutical Quality Control Labs (7/93).
Read FDA Guidance

3. American Type Culture Collection (ATCC). Reference Strains: How Many Passages Are Too Many?
Visit ATCC

4. United States Pharmacopeia (USP). General Chapters 〈60〉, 〈61〉, 〈62〉 and 〈71〉, as applicable to the test being performed.
Visit United States Pharmacopeia

Share this article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts